I suggest the jumbo pencils, if they’re available. I currently have “milk” and “rust”. I highly recommend “milk” as it is a great base that will not effect the color of shadows other than to make them appear brighter.
If you are not already a member, feel free to use the button in my sidebar for an invite. I get a $10 credit if you register through that link. You can also join without the affiliate link 🙂